I don’t understand group work. I have never understood group work.
I think this long standing disdain for collaborative practice has informed my current career path in the humanities and my decision to abandon any thoughts of pursuing a career in a lab-based setting. This does not mean that I’ve abandoned any sense of civility in human interaction. I fully support being beyond friendly to assorted departmental colleagues, professional peers, archivists and librarians, and generally anyone I happen to come across that I have not pre-identifed as a complete bobo.
I like to think I project these ideas pretty clearly. Particularly if you’ve peripherally known me for an extended period of time. I like to think I communicate something along the lines of “No, let’s not be friends. That’s too strong and too much of a commitment. Plus, if we were going to be “friends” this would already have taken place. However, as a concession, we can pretend to like one another out in public and not be overtly hostile to one another assuming neither one of us steps out of line. ‘K?”
Imagine my surprise when I was invited to join a, well, scheduled daily library dissertation study group of sorts. And then imagine my surprise when I was invited a second time to join this potential clusterfuck of library interaction. The premise is (if I fully understand it) that we will each select a day of the week during which we affirm to be at said library to function as both a) guardian of the possession of others should they need to run the bathroom, get coffee, stake out a point from which they will shoot a poison blow dart at someone walking by in trackpants and flip flops and b) serve as a motivating source by way of making others feel that they are responsible to show up so that the waiter (one waiting) won’t spend the day working alone. While I see the value of the first point, because packing everything up can be a bitch when you only have mere seconds to load your blow dart tube and find an appropriate hiding space, the value of the second is lost on me.
If I’m going to the library to get work done, work that is clearly of both great quantity and great import if I need to generate a seven day schedule to accomplish it, why would I care that there’s someone in the library waiting for me to arrive? Yes, a friendly face is nice, and yes, dissertating can become a fully isolating activity if one let’s it. And if this point of social isolation had been brought up, perhaps I would have been slightly more sympathetic to the idea. But this notion of “Then you’ll have a study buddy! Or several!” is lost on me. If I need to get work done, I personally find my secluded corner of the world and emerge when it’s done. I’ll see a friendly face after I’ve come up for air from either the bowels of a library or depths of a research archive. Certainly not during. We can meet up to drink after I’m done writing the several pages I’ve allocated to get through for the day; not check in to see when one another are grabbing coffee during the writing process.
Because I think we all know what’s going to happen: There will be approximately 22 minutes of work, and then something funny/ludicrous/surprising/awful will strike one of us, and then that person will share it with the group and there will be some sort of mini reaction and we’ll get back to work. But by that time it’s too late. The precedent has been set. Then there’s only 13 minutes of work between the next distraction. And then it’s coffee which turns into lunch. And then the day is fucked.
Or worse: there will be that person who’s part of the group who, even if they keep their mouth shut during the day, will want to talk afterwards about what they did during the day. And since I barely care about what I’m working on at this point, I REALLY don’t care what niche topic of the academic record you’ve chosen to carve out for yourself. Broadstrokes: maybe. Elevator pitch: sure. An extended discussion of what new insight you’ve come to after analyzing late 1930s automobile trade magazines: not a chance.
Or even worse: you find out that you’ve been grouped in with a mouth breather. And then they would have to be clubbed to death. And it is my experience that once you bludgeon someone in a library, the library administration frowns upon allowing you future access to their collections. Even if you provide your own cudgel.
Maybe this marks me as hopelessly antisocial. I don’t think so. I think this just makes me someone who likes to read a book and type on his laptop without a support group that I did not request hovering nearby.
Ok, time to pack up.

